Pages

Barcelona: Why Xavi Hernández shouldn’t be built up as the coach to ‘save’ the Catalan giants

Barcelona: Why Xavi Hernández shouldn’t be built up as the coach to ‘save’ the Catalan giants

Recently announcing his retirement at the end of this season ahead of a move into coaching, Xavi Hernández still has a long way to go before he will be ready to lead the elite.


But with expectations in Barcelona huge, does he already have a thankless task ahead of him?





Barcelona’s midfielder Xavi Hernandez celebrates one of many titles he won at the Camp Nou



4




Barcelona’s midfielder Xavi Hernandez celebrates one of many titles he won at the Camp Nou



Xavi has slowly been winding down his playing career for four years, but with the confirmation that he will hang up his boots for good at the end of this season, there is already an expectation that his coaching career will start at breakneck speed.


The midfielder, who was the embodiment of Barcelona’s all-conquering style that peaked under Pep Guardiola, has in his absence from Catalonia been elevated to the status of a deity-like saviour figure who will return to the Camp Nou and orchestrate a new era of all-passing, all-conquering brilliance. All before he has done any real coaching of note.


The expectations are far greater than anything Pep Guardiola was faced with when he took over as Barcelona coach in 2008. If anything, a vocal proportion of onlookers expected that decision to put a relatively inexperienced coach in charge of the tricky post-Frank Rijkaard transition at the Camp Nou to end in failure. There was certainly nothing like the kind of widespread assumed brilliance that has already been attached to Xavi and his forthcoming coaching career.















And even if Guardiola was hardly a seasoned veteran when he took charge of Barça’s seniors, nor was it true that he dived straight into the deep end. First, there was the five months he spent in Mexico with Juanma Lillo at Dorados de Sinaloa. Though in principle signed as a player, injuries kept Guardiola out of action for long stretches, and he spent more of his time in Mexico instructing younger teammates on their positioning after training sessions, detailing Lillo’s drills in his notebook, and providing information about opponents for the manager.


Then there was his year with Barça B, grafting in the Spanish lower leagues.





Pep Guardiola was allowed to work his way up to managing Barcelona’s first-team



4




Pep Guardiola was allowed to work his way up to managing Barcelona’s first-team



It was there that he had his first experience of chasing a trophy as a coach (a successful chase, winning the fourth division). That season out of the spotlight allowed Pep to put into practice the concepts he had learned from Lillo, old mentor Johan Cruyff, and Marcelo Bielsa. It also allowed him time to refine ideas, and equally important, time to make mistakes that is not afforded at a senior side.


Expecting Xavi to take charge of the Blaugrana without a similar easing-in experience would be a mistake. The midfielder, who is no fool, is well aware of that too. Speaking to Catalunya Radio’s Ricard Torquemada last year, the Catalan outlined a less demanding beginning in the coaching world.


“I’d like to start coaching here in Qatar. I think it’s an ideal environment to get experience, test myself, organise staff. Then other things will come after that. Starting here would give me more security, in the short-term I think my first step as a coach will be here.”





Prying eyes will be scrutinising how much Xavi learnt from Guardiola.



4




Prying eyes will be scrutinising how much Xavi learnt from Guardiola.



And though he seems to have the right idea about a gradual learning experience, there is one red flag regarding Xavi’s potential as a coach that shouldn’t be overlooked. The playmaker has made no secret of the kind of football he wants his teams to play – even the press release confirming his retirement referred to the influence of Cruyff and La Masia – and that has only furthered the appetite to see him back in Barcelona.


But in contrast to Guardiola, who rarely criticises the style or approach of other teams, Xavi has a habit of straying into the territory of dogma, which doesn’t bode well.


In interviews the midfielder frequently criticises sides who play less proactive football, going as far as to call them boring. “Teams that play 4-5-1 bore me, teams who don’t want the ball. It’s useful to see things I’m not going to do when I’m a coach,” he said in November.





Al-Sadd’s Xavi Hernandez vies for the ball with Al-Ahli’s Claudemir



4




Al-Sadd’s Xavi Hernandez vies for the ball with Al-Ahli’s Claudemir



It’s a far cry from Guardiola congratulating Bristol City boss Lee Johnson after Man City’s Carabao Cup semi-final in 2018 for example, when he noted that the opposition may have played “with long balls” but that they nonetheless “came here trying to play”.


Guardiola’s open-mindedness and willing to learn from a variety of coaches and styles has kept him on the top for all of these years and allowed his sides to evolve. It’s far from clear that Xavi possesses that same willingness to learn and adapt.


We will only find out for sure once he starts to try and put his ideas into practice, and there is no guarantee he will be good enough to do that at Barcelona – despite the huge hype over his potential.






Premier League relegation battle: The table, odds for the drop, including Cardiff City, Brighton and Southampton's fixtures In all honesty this season's Premier League relegation battle
Premier League relegation run-in: Which clubs are going down




May 08, 2013 · From knocking Liverpool off their perch to squeaky-bum time, a selection of sayings by the league's longest-serving manager It was like a funeral out there." On Manchester City's Carlos Tévez
Fans: Knocking the Scousers off their perch was the best




Rangers star Alfredo Morelos 'dreams of playing in much better, more competitive league' amid Leicester and Borussia Dortmund transfer interest Rangers star Alfredo Morelos says he wants to play in a 'much better, more competitive league'. The 22-year-old, who has been linked with moves to Leicester talkSPORT 1 week ago
Kylian Mbappe hints at PSG exit, Alexis Sanchez's desperate
fussboll.com/2019/05/20/kylian-mbappe-hints-at-psg-exit-alexis-sanchezs-desperate-bid-to-leave-manchester-united-city-identify-vincent-kompany-replacement/
Rangers star Alfredo Morelos 'dreams of playing in much better, more competitive league' amid Leicester and Borussia Dortmund transfer interest World Football May 20, 2019 José Mourinho revisionism is lazy, unproductive, and reactionary
Rangers Archives - SportsAlert




Liverpool 2005 vs 2019: Who makes this combined Reds XI ahead of Champions League final? Liverpool are going for Champions League No.6 when they face Tottenham in the final in Madrid on
Barcelona vs Liverpool: Who makes the combined XI ahead of



The summer transfer window is open and negotiations on new Transfer Insight from Every Premier League Club Dean Jones One player B/R has been told they are looking into is Solly March of
1 Realistic Move Each Premier League Side Should Make in


Tottenham news: Paul Coyte dreams of introducing Spurs as 'Champions League winners' and reveals Jose Mou Madrid madness Spurs' on-pitch announcer and the host of Sportsday on talkSPORT 2 will be on the pitch in Madrid on Saturday to announce the team and - possibly - introduce the winner.
Tottenham news: Paul Coyte dreams of introducing Spurs as



Tottenham Hotspur fans were going wild on Twitter ahead of their clash with Manchester City as they realised Vincent Janssen had returned to the matchday squad. Absent since August 2017, when he played one minute in a 2-1 defeat to Chelsea at Wembley Stadium, the Dutchman could now play a key role for the club.
Vincent Janssen: Tottenham fans hail striker as Dutchman


Transfers, Sir Alex and Virgil van Dijk - Solskjaer's first


Entire Roma squad attend Daniele de Rossi's farewell press


Who is Nicolas Tagliafico? The 'new Zanetti' who could replace Monreal and Kolasinac at Arsenal. Arsenal transfer news takes a closer look at the Argentine international who has been linked with a summer move to the Emirates Stadium



Sports Mole provides team news, predicted lineups and a full preview of Sunday's Premier League clash between Crystal Palace and Manchester City. The Citizens suffered a rare defeat in midweek
Crystal Palace vs Liverpool RESULT - Premier League at



Adrian Durham has made a passionate plea for Scott Brown to 'grow up' and use his status to 'be the force for good Scottish football needs'. Brown was accused of deliberately winding-up the Rangers players in the Old Firm derby on Sunday, which ended in a 2-1 Celtic victory.
Scott Brown: Celtic captain told to 'grow up' for the sake of

0 comments:

Post a Comment